First off, this film is better than what some of the review sites are telling you. Rottentomatoes.com gave it a 24%, ya, the "I know the basics of green lantern but nothing else" crowd certainly showed up to spew some hate on a film that does not deserve such a low rating.
Now I confess, I'm not the biggest GL fan, in fact I have yet to read any of the recent event books (brightest day / blackest night, sinestro corps war etc), however I have read some GL, mostly the modern books featuring Kyle Rayner as GL.
What's good about this film
-Ryan Reynolds was a perfect choice to play Hal Jordan, he's in excellent shape, has a great comedic timing, and can act.
-Blake Lively is the love interest...ya try hating on that.
-For those who don't know about GL, it's like a modern day star wars, can't ever go wrong with that
-There's 'too much CG' ya that's good in this case
-the notions of fear and will power were excellently used
What's bad about the film
-came out at a time when there is too much to compete with
-the essence of the character might be too 'out there' for casual viewers to appreciate
-the film tries to do a little too much
-the film doesn't really have a strong 'bad guy'
So one of the many criticisms was that the film was too much like all the other super hero films in terms of set up. Well ya man, it's an origin story and the writers of these films have the origin story down to a science. Let's see, you start off by showing some scenes that seemingly have nothing to do with main character, then some danger / tragedy happens, then cut to light-hearted average joe day with main character, then love interest is casually introduced, then maybe cuts to scenes of bad guy becoming bad guy, or scenes of the 'other world' in the case of films that have other worlds like Asgard in Thor. Then cuts to the discovery of main character to something that turns them into the hero, then some knowledge about what it is to be that hero, then some training, then a mini fight, then some soul searching, then big fight, then bad guy seemingly dies, but you don't know for sure, then happy ending.
GL follows this formula almost to a tee, and if you look at most of the comic book films' first film you can see this is pretty much how it runs. So ya, it's nothing new, but even spiderman followed this formula. So this isn't really something to frown upon, I mean it is but it isn't, you have to introduce the hero, the love interest, the villain, their motivation for being a villain, the universe and then show how the average joe handles being a hero and then some fighting etc. You have to show all that in the first film because there are more people who are casual watchers than there are who are hardcore fans, and you have to cater to everyone.
So this isn't a problem for me. The next issue that critics had was the amount of CG in the film. Ya when the costume of the hero including the face mask is CG you know there's a lot, but who cares? I mean really you're gonna bitch because there's too MUCH CG? the film's based off a guy who travels to other planets, talks to aliens regularly, and has a ring that can make whatever he imagines a reality. Ya I can see it now "no we need to keep this film real, so when you use the ring to create the gun, we're going to give you a real gun just painted green, that'll win over the viewer right?" This isn't batman, there's no 'realism' with GL it's science-fiction with super heroes.
So so far, critics seem to be just un-informed bigots who have seen one super hero film and have labeled every other to come after as 'redundant, over-stylized child's play' and not really worth their consideration.
However, if you really want to know the 'quality' of a character or franchise, wait for the second film. The first one is always a wash, it's the origin, but the second film will show you if it the franchise has legs, because now everyone is familiar with the characters and universe, so if the second film isn't compelling than you know it's a failure. The first film will always bring in audiences because a lot of people are curious about the hero "who's Green Lantern?".
Not all these super hero films can be batman begins, so if you're into comics at all, you'll appreciate Green Lantern, if you're not into comics but know superman and spiderman, and aren't an art house film snob and just want to be entertained you'll like this film too.
If you're an 'adult' and are looking for something to 'really make you think' then don't see this because you're not capable of having fun.
Overall 3/5
it's in the same 'quality' as fantastic four and thor. it's not batman begins or punisher, it's not gritty or 'real' it's a fun CG summer romp and unless you're looking to hate it you should enjoy it.
-Chris
0 Comments